December 22nd, 2005 (10:55 pm)
Winter light is the second part of the Bergman's "God of Silence" trilogy! (and the best one i think)
The film starts with the image of a service and ends with the same image.
The big director "Ingmar Bergman" has made a wonderfull story includes striking details, theatrical views.
It seems as a story of few people(pastor Thomas, Marta, Jonas ... )
live in a small village, who are wonder about the silence of God!
But, beside its religion concept, this story tells the pastor Thomas. His hell lives in, his paradoxes feels/thinks about God , his emotionally dying
Yes! Thomas Ericson lives in his hell, because he has lost his belief and connection to
life after his wife died. (Gunnar Bjorstand is really great with his iced , cool
face and insensitive stand as role of unhappy pastor)

Marta, she tries to create an ideal love for Thomas to fill emptiness feels inside her.
The act which marta reads the letter (wrote for Thomas) is the summit of the Ingrid Thulin acting at this story!

And the other hopeless and unbelieving person is a fisherman Jonas.
With his sad face and soulless eyes, Max Von Sydow is great to
make us understand how he feels himself nothingness through the
life.

While trying to answer Jona's question "Why must we live?" Tomas
lets all his suffering out but he cant prevent him(Jonas) from commit
suicide:
TOMAS - Listen to me, Jonas. You know that my wife died four years ago.
I loved her. Life was over, for me; i am not afraid of death, and there
was no reason at the time for me to keep on living.
Jonas listens carefully.
TOMAS - I kept on living not for myself, but to be useful. You have to
know that i used to have big dreams. When i was a child i wanted to be
a very important person, and my mother used to protect me from every
kind of evil, of danger. (...) me and my god lived in another world,
such a special and tidy world, where everything looked perfect. All
around, in the real life, there was pain and suffering, but i could not
see it, i turned my eyes towards my god.
Jonas looked anxious, worried.
TOMAS - You must understand. I am not a good clergyman. I chose my
vocation because my father and my mother were religious people, i
wanted to please them. Then i became a clergyman and i believed in God.
An absurd, personal and paternal god, who loved all the men but me
above all (...) A god who could protect me all the time; from the fear
of death, of life. I rented and built with my own hands this
suggestion-god. You see, Jonas, my terrible mistake? Can you imagine my
prayers? I prayed to an echo-god, who always gave to me benevolent and
reassuring answers.
Jonas is nervous.
TOMAS - Every time i compared my god to the reality i saw around, it
appeared ugly and abominable to me, a spider-god... a monster. That's
why i protected my god from life and light. I pushed it next to me in
darkness and solitude. The only person who was allowed to see my god
was my wife. She encouraged me, she helped me, she stopped all the
gaps.. my indifference to preach the Gospel, my jealous hatred for
Christ.
JONAS - Now i really have to go.
TOMAS - No, no. No, you don't have to go. You must understand why i
tell you so much about me. i want you to see which miserable person,
which deranged poor man is standing in front of you. I am not a pastor.
I am a beggar who needs your help.
JONAS - I am very grateful to you, but now i must go (...)
TOMAS - Just one more while (...). Let's admit god doesn't exist, which
difference does it make? Life becomes understandable. What a relief!
Death becomes the dissolving of souls. Men's cruelty, their loneliness,
their fears, everything becomes clear and transparent. The
incomprehensible suffering doesn't need explanations anymore. The
stars, the world and the skies created themselves and gave life one
another. There's not a creator of the world.
Jonas looks at the door.
TOMAS - You and me are both alone, we both betrayed the only human
conditions.. to live with the other men; for this we are miserable,
joyless and filled with anguish (...) You must live Jonas. Summer will
surely come, darkness won't last forever. You have your strawberry
field and your flowered jasmines. Think how much perfumed are they.
It's heaven on earth, Jonas. It's a reason for life.